What people mean by old English
Search for old English font and most results show blackletter: the angular, tightly packed script that printers used across western Europe before roman type took over. Newspapers kept it in mastheads long after, which is why it still reads as formal and slightly antique.
Strictly speaking it is a family, not one face. Textura is the dense book hand, Fraktur the German variant with broken curves, and rotunda the rounder Italian form. The characters on this page come from Unicode's mathematical blackletter block, which covers the ordinary Latin alphabet in a single style.
What the copy actually contains
Each result is a string of characters, not a font file. Every ordinary A to Z has a blackletter counterpart, so a word made of plain Latin letters converts completely. Digits, punctuation, accented letters, and letters from other scripts have no counterpart and stay as they are, which produces a visible jump in style partway through a phrase.
That is also why the effect survives a paste but not an edit: you cannot select the string and choose another weight, because the weight is encoded in which characters you pasted.
Where it holds up
Headers, posters, a channel name, a shirt design, a logo sketch, and any place where the lettering is seen large and read once. It also suits a short all-caps word: blackletter capitals are the most decorated and the most recognisable part of the style.
Where it falls down
Anything that has to be read at a glance: a follower list, a comment, a caption, a form field. Blackletter at twelve pixels is a dark band rather than a word. Keep it to a name or a heading, and put the explanation in ordinary letters underneath.
The same rule applies to fields. Usernames, email addresses, coupon codes, and search boxes either reject the characters or store a version that no longer matches what people type, so keep those in plain letters.
Picking a weight
Three related styles appear in the list. Plain blackletter is the closest to a classic old English look. Bold blackletter and double-struck give heavier, more graphic versions that hold up better on a poster or a thumbnail. Serif italic and script sit nearby if you want decorative lettering without the dense texture.
Type your phrase above and compare all of them on the same words before you commit. A phrase of two words shows the spacing between letters better than a single long word.
More specimen pages
For readable decorative alternatives see cursive fonts, fancy fonts, and small caps. For weight without decoration, use bold text; for the full list on one screen, open the font changer.